user_088f1dVerified Diner Dined on Mar 6, 2026The Salted Caramel Pizookie at BJ’s sits at second place on the menu right behind the chocolate chunk Pizookie both in its full-size form, as well as in its mini-size form. That says a lot, because that speaks to how great both flavors are in general. They can be ordered in their mini form as a trio. On the flip side, the minis can also be ordered two at a time with alternating and/or identical flavors as a bundle for $5 on Pizookie Tuesdays.