Sugar Beach Bake Shop

Sugar Beach Bake Shop is a beloved Kīhei bakery that handcrafts every item daily from the freshest ingredients, including sweet cream butter, Madagascar Bourbon vanilla, fresh-picked lilikoi, Dole Bananas and Pineapples, and Maui Meyer Lemon zest. Inspired by local flavors, their ever-changing selection of desserts spans mango cheesecake, lilikoi key lime pie, coconut cream pie, and banana cream pie. Their hot, fresh Malasadas are a standout favorite among visitors and locals alike, with the plain sugar variety drawing particular praise. The shop also serves fresh-brewed Hawaiian OMA coffee and house-made lemonades throughout the day. Located on South Kihei Road, the casual, welcoming atmosphere suits solo outings, family visits, and everything in between.