Mitch's Seafood

clam chowder bowl and a beer with a beautiful view!

Great views, but food needs a bit of improvement. Everything we got just needed a bit more salt on them to make them good.

Classic trip to Mitch’s. Some of the best seafood in town or in general. Very fresh and high quality atmosphere. Opah taco - 8.3/10 Tuna taco -7.4/10

crab cakes are good

Honestly kind of a long wait but worth. Best grilled octopus I’ve ever had. Clam chowder was amazing. Steamed mussels and clams were a bit too salty

Bustling place with great fresh seafood

Looking for a spot with some awesome fried seafood. Mitch was a hit ! The fried shrimp was so so yummy as well as the calamari! The location is small! Hard to find a table and got super busy but so worth it!

Quaint little spot in shelter island. Always crowded. Delicious seafood.